# tarte Shape Tape vs Shape Tape Creamy

**Question answered:** Should I choose tarte Shape Tape Concealer or Shape Tape Creamy Concealer?

**Short answer:** Choose Shape Tape Concealer if you want the original full-coverage formula with a natural matte finish, especially for oily skin or spot concealing. Choose Shape Tape Creamy Concealer if your under-eyes are dry and you want the same full coverage with what tarte calls a moisturizing matte finish. Both list fragrance and several fragrance allergens.

By Nora Ellison. Published 2026-10-28. Data is taken from manufacturer labels; the products have not been tested.

## What this means for you

### Start with what you notice

Both are full-coverage concealers for dark circles and spots. Pick by how your under-eye skin behaves: if concealers crease into dry lines, try the creamier one; if they slide off oily skin, the original.

### The ingredient names, translated

The original uses a silicone base with clays and powders for a matte finish. The Creamy version adds humectants such as glycerin and hydroxyethyl urea, plus more emollients, for a softer feel. Both list fragrance and allergens such as limonene, linalool and geraniol.

### How to decide

- Oily skin, or mostly spot concealing? Shape Tape Concealer.
- Dry under-eyes, or concealer settles into lines? Shape Tape Creamy Concealer.
- Avoiding fragrance near your eyes? Neither; both list fragrance.

### What to expect

Coverage and finish depend on shade match, prep and how much you apply. A full-coverage concealer can look heavy if overused. We haven't tested either product.

General guidance, not a test of these products: [AAD: how makeup can cause acne](https://www.aad.org/public/diseases/acne/causes/makeup); [FDA: fragrances in cosmetics](https://www.fda.gov/cosmetics/cosmetic-ingredients/fragrances-cosmetics). Each product's label source is linked on its product page.

## Finish decides it

[tarte Shape Tape Concealer](product:tarte-shape-tape-concealer) is tarte's original full-coverage concealer with a natural matte finish. Its list starts with water, cyclopentasiloxane, cyclohexasiloxane, butylene glycol and PEG-10 dimethicone, with shea butter, licorice root and sunflower seed oil further down.

[tarte Shape Tape Creamy Concealer](product:tarte-shape-tape-creamy-concealer) keeps full coverage with what tarte calls a moisturizing matte finish. Its list adds glycerin, caprylic/capric triglyceride, hydroxyethyl urea and several silicones and esters.

> **Skin Realist check:** under-eye creasing is often too much product, not the wrong product. Try half the amount before you blame the formula.

## Label differences worth knowing

Both list the same set of fragrance allergens. tarte's pages report respondent surveys for both formulas. For tips, see our [makeup for acne-prone skin guide](/articles/makeup-for-acne-prone-skin/) and our [Shape Tape vs Dermablend comparison](/comparisons/tarte-shape-tape-vs-dermablend-cover-care-concealer/).

## Manufacturer sources

- [tarte Shape Tape Concealer](https://tartecosmetics.com/products/shape-tape-concealer)
- [tarte Shape Tape Creamy Concealer](https://tartecosmetics.com/products/shape-tape-creamy-concealer)

Sources and label-check dates are recorded on the product pages.

| Product | Key ingredients | Skin types | Fragrance | Flagged ingredients | Size | Source | Buy |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [tarte Shape Tape™ Concealer](https://dermalguide.com/products/tarte-shape-tape-concealer/) | Brand doesn't name one | Brand doesn't say | Scent ingredients flagged | amyl cinnamal, benzyl salicylate, geraniol, hexyl cinnamal, hydroxycitronellal, limonene, linalool, fragrance/parfum, Fragrance (Parfum), Limonene, Linalool, Geraniol, Benzyl Salicylate, Hexyl Cinnamal | Brand doesn't list it | [Manufacturer label](https://tartecosmetics.com/products/shape-tape-concealer), checked 2026-10-10 | [Amazon (affiliate)](https://amzn.to/4dzHAlo) |
| [tarte Shape Tape™ Creamy Concealer](https://dermalguide.com/products/tarte-shape-tape-creamy-concealer/) | Brand doesn't name one | Brand doesn't say | Scent ingredients flagged | fragrance/parfum, benzyl salicylate, hexyl cinnamal, limonene, hydroxycitronellal, geraniol, amyl cinnamal, linalool, raspberry ketone, Fragrance (Parfum), Limonene, Linalool, Geraniol, Benzyl Salicylate, Hexyl Cinnamal, Isopropyl Myristate | Brand doesn't list it | [Manufacturer label](https://tartecosmetics.com/products/shape-tape-creamy-concealer), checked 2026-10-10 | [Amazon (affiliate)](https://amzn.to/4yiUuf0) |

## Which to choose

Consider tarte Shape Tape™ Concealer when: You want the original natural matte finish, especially on oily skin; You mainly conceal spots and redness.

Consider tarte Shape Tape™ Creamy Concealer when: Your under-eye area is dry and you want a moisturizing matte finish; You want glycerin and hydroxyethyl urea in the formula.


## Questions

### Are they the same coverage?

tarte describes both as full coverage. The difference it states is the finish: natural matte vs moisturizing matte.

### Do they contain fragrance?

Yes. Both list fragrance/parfum, limonene, linalool, geraniol, benzyl salicylate and hexyl cinnamal.

### Which has the longer ingredient list?

Shape Tape Creamy lists 74 ingredients, including several plant oils, butters and hyaluronic acid forms; the original lists 40. The Creamy version also lists isopropyl myristate.